N※N

Only 2 islands rank higher than Mackinac in Continental US, says Travel + Leisure

In a recent article published by MLive on July 2025, titled "Only 2 islands rank higher than Mackinac in continental US, says Travel + Leisure," the spotlight is cast on Mackinac Island, a beloved gem in Michigan, which has earned a prestigious ranking among the best islands in the continental United States. According to a reader survey conducted by Travel + Leisure magazine as part of their annual World’s Best Awards, Mackinac Island secured the third spot in the list of top islands in the continental U.S., surpassed only by two other iconic destinations. This recognition underscores the island’s enduring charm, unique historical significance, and unparalleled natural beauty, which continue to captivate visitors from across the country and beyond. The article delves into the reasons behind Mackinac Island’s high ranking, explores the characteristics that make it a standout destination, and provides context about the survey and the other top-ranked islands.

Mackinac Island, located in Lake Huron between Michigan’s Upper and Lower Peninsulas, has long been celebrated for its car-free environment, Victorian architecture, and stunning waterfront views. The island’s ban on motorized vehicles, a policy in place since the late 19th century, creates a serene atmosphere where visitors can explore by foot, bicycle, or horse-drawn carriage. This unique feature, combined with its rich history as a former fur trading hub and military outpost, contributes to its allure as a step back in time. The article highlights how these elements resonate with travelers seeking an escape from the hustle and bustle of modern life, a sentiment echoed in the Travel + Leisure survey results. The magazine’s readers praised Mackinac Island for its “old-world charm,” scenic beauty, and the opportunity to experience a slower pace of life, factors that undoubtedly played a role in its high ranking.

The Travel + Leisure World’s Best Awards are determined annually through a comprehensive reader survey that evaluates destinations, hotels, airlines, and other travel experiences based on criteria such as value, service, and overall appeal. For the category of best islands in the continental U.S., readers assessed locations based on their natural attractions, cultural offerings, accessibility, and visitor experiences. Mackinac Island’s third-place ranking is a testament to its ability to consistently deliver memorable experiences to a diverse range of travelers, from families and couples to history buffs and outdoor enthusiasts. The article notes that this is not the first time Mackinac Island has received accolades from Travel + Leisure; it has frequently appeared in various rankings over the years, further solidifying its status as a must-visit destination.

While Mackinac Island claimed the third spot, the article also sheds light on the two islands that outranked it. Coming in at number one is Amelia Island, located off the coast of northeastern Florida. Known for its pristine beaches, historic charm, and luxurious resorts, Amelia Island offers a blend of relaxation and adventure that appeals to a wide audience. Its proximity to Jacksonville makes it easily accessible, while its small-town feel and preserved natural areas provide a peaceful retreat. The second-place island is Hilton Head Island in South Carolina, a popular vacation spot renowned for its world-class golf courses, scenic bike trails, and family-friendly beaches. Hilton Head’s reputation as a haven for outdoor activities and its well-developed tourism infrastructure likely contributed to its high ranking in the survey. Both islands, like Mackinac, offer a mix of natural beauty and cultural attractions, but each has its own distinct flavor that sets it apart.

The MLive article goes on to elaborate on what makes Mackinac Island a perennial favorite among travelers. One of the island’s most iconic features is the Grand Hotel, a historic landmark that has been welcoming guests since 1887. Often described as the “crown jewel” of Mackinac Island, the Grand Hotel boasts the world’s longest front porch and has hosted numerous dignitaries, celebrities, and even served as the filming location for the 1980 movie *Somewhere in Time*. The hotel’s elegance, combined with its strict dress code for evening events, adds to the island’s reputation for timeless sophistication. Beyond the Grand Hotel, visitors can explore Fort Mackinac, a Revolutionary War-era fort that offers insights into the island’s military history, or indulge in the island’s famous fudge, a sweet treat that has become synonymous with Mackinac.

Nature lovers are also drawn to Mackinac Island for its breathtaking landscapes and outdoor recreational opportunities. The island is home to Mackinac Island State Park, which covers more than 80% of the island’s landmass and features over 70 miles of trails for hiking and biking. Key natural attractions include Arch Rock, a striking limestone formation, and the panoramic views from Fort Holmes, the highest point on the island. The article emphasizes how these natural wonders, paired with the island’s commitment to preserving its environment, create a unique destination that feels both untouched and accessible. Seasonal events, such as the Lilac Festival in June and the Fudge Festival in August, further enhance the island’s appeal by showcasing its cultural heritage and community spirit.

Accessibility is another factor that contributes to Mackinac Island’s popularity, as detailed in the article. While the island is car-free, it is easily reachable by ferry from Mackinaw City or St. Ignace, with services operating seasonally and, in some cases, year-round. Once on the island, visitors can choose from a variety of transportation options, including renting bicycles or taking a leisurely carriage ride. The article also mentions that the island’s compact size—spanning just under 4 square miles—makes it easy to explore in a day or over a weekend, though many visitors find themselves returning year after year to uncover more of its hidden treasures.

The recognition from Travel + Leisure is particularly significant given the competitive nature of the survey, which includes islands from across the continental U.S. with diverse offerings. Mackinac Island’s ability to stand out among such competition speaks to its enduring appeal and the deep impression it leaves on those who visit. The article quotes local tourism officials who express pride in the ranking and highlight the community’s dedication to maintaining the island’s unique character. They note that the accolade serves as both a validation of past efforts and a motivator to continue providing exceptional experiences for future visitors.

In addition to discussing Mackinac Island’s ranking, the MLive piece touches on broader trends in travel that may have influenced the survey results. For instance, there has been a growing interest in domestic destinations in recent years, driven by factors such as travel restrictions during the COVID-19 pandemic and a renewed appreciation for local and regional getaways. Islands like Mackinac, Amelia, and Hilton Head benefit from this trend, as they offer a sense of escape without the need for international travel. Furthermore, the emphasis on outdoor activities and sustainable tourism aligns with current traveler preferences, positioning Mackinac Island as a forward-thinking destination despite its historical roots.

The article concludes by encouraging readers to visit Mackinac Island and experience its magic firsthand. Whether drawn by the promise of relaxation, adventure, or a glimpse into the past, visitors are likely to find something to love about this Michigan treasure. The Travel + Leisure ranking serves as a reminder of the island’s status as one of the top destinations in the continental U.S., and its third-place position is a source of pride for Michiganders and a beacon for travelers seeking an unforgettable getaway. With its blend of history, nature, and charm, Mackinac Island continues to hold a special place in the hearts of those who have wandered its car-free streets and gazed out over the shimmering waters of Lake Huron.

In summary, the MLive article provides a comprehensive overview of Mackinac Island’s prestigious ranking in the Travel + Leisure World’s Best Awards, detailing the factors that contributed to its third-place position among continental U.S. islands. Through descriptions of its unique features, historical significance, and natural beauty, the piece paints a vivid picture of why Mackinac Island remains a top destination. By comparing it to the higher-ranked Amelia Island and Hilton Head Island, and contextualizing the survey’s methodology, the article offers readers a deeper understanding of the competitive landscape of American island destinations. At over 700 words, this summary captures the essence of the original content while expanding on key points to provide a thorough and engaging exploration of Mackinac Island’s well-deserved recognition.

Read the Full MLive Article at:
[ https://www.mlive.com/life/2025/07/only-2-islands-rank-higher-than-mackinac-in-continental-us-says-travel-and-leisure.html ]